CLIMATE FINANCE WORK PROGRAMME: AT BREAKING POINT
Negotiations on the Climate Finance Work Programme have reached a critical juncture. The EU’s sudden request to set aside the current draft in favour of a new proposal drew sharp criticism from the G77 and China, marking a breakdown between the main negotiating blocs. The co-facilitators will now consult with the Presidency on how to proceed with the talks.
Inside the COP31 negotiating room dedicated to the Climate Finance Work Programme—where talks were already proving complex—the situation deteriorated abruptly on Tuesday evening, with the session brought to a premature halt at the request of the G77 and China. The backlash was triggered by an intervention from the European Union, which rejected the revised draft prepared by the co-facilitators and proposed instead adopting a new, brief text focused strictly on procedural matters.
The breakdown came at the end of a day already rife with controversy. Earlier in the morning, rumours had circulated suggesting the European Union might push for a “no-text” outcome—effectively leaving the track without a final decision. Oxfam International voiced concern over these corridor whispers, warning that failing to reach a decision would leave the modalities for implementing existing climate finance commitments undefined. Speaking at a press conference in the early afternoon, EU Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra responded to the criticism by calling for negotiations to focus on the efficient implementation of strategies and commitments agreed at previous COPs, facilitating access to already pledged funds, and ensuring their accessibility.
Parties then reconvened at 7:00 pm to discuss the new draft text circulated earlier that day by the co-facilitators for this track, Norway and Azerbaijan. While the text had streamlined the preamble and certain passages, it retained multiple bracketed options across all the core points of disagreement inherited from the Bonn intersessionals and an inconclusive first week of negotiations: the timeline of the Work Programme (whether it is yet to be launched or already underway); its scope (whether it covers Article 9 as a whole or focuses specifically on Article 9.1); and its implementation modalities.
The session opened with several questions regarding the structure of the text, which was less linear and intuitive than the previous iteration. Following these initial requests for clarification came the EU’s watershed intervention. Taking the floor, the EU representative stated unequivocally that the bloc would not engage with this new draft, arguing that it introduced too many contentious and novel elements to serve as a basis for any agreement at this stage of the negotiations. In effect, the EU asked Parties to set aside earlier discussions in light of what it deemed irreconcilable differences, and instead focus on a one-page procedural draft.
Immediately given the floor, the representative of the G77 and China requested a brief suspension to allow the group to coordinate. When talks resumed, the delegation announced that it could not continue working at this stage, stating that Parties needed to consult with their respective Heads of Delegation and accusing the EU—albeit without naming it directly—of acting in bad faith. The Arab Group then took the floor to reject the option of considering any new document proposed by the EU, insisting that discussions continue on the points put forward by the G77 and China and emphasising that the bloc represents over three-quarters of the world’s population.
Tentative attempts by the co-facilitators, New Zealand, and Switzerland to bridge the divide and reopen the negotiating table quickly collapsed. First the G77 and China, and then the African Group, reiterated their refusal to continue the session. At that point, the co-facilitators had no choice but to adjourn the meeting and accept delegations’ request to consult with the Presidency on how to move the discussions forward.
In a sign of how charged the moment was, many delegates lingered in the room long after the adjournment—some exchanging views and dissecting the sudden turn of events, others reaching out across negotiating blocs to explore potential compromises, and still others conferring within their own ranks. It is hard to place bets on the fate of this workstream, at least within this COP. It now falls to the Presidency to provide guidance on how to proceed with an agenda item whose mandate officially expired yesterday. One thing is certain: the clock is ticking, and the Climate Finance Work Programme remains deadlocked.
Article by Marco Colpo, Italian Climate Network delegate at COP31 in Antalya.
Cover image: photo UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth
