THE BELEM 4X PLEDGE AND THE DIVIDE BETWEEN POLITICS AND ACTIVISM ON THE FUTURE OF FUELS
The Belém 4X Pledge on Sustainable Fuels, co-sponsored by Brazil, Italy and Japan and supported by India
Even before COP30 began, an initiative launched at the Pre-COP event revealed the first rift between the “political” choices of countries on the one hand, and civil society and climate activism on the other.
The Belém 4X Pledge on Sustainable Fuels was launched during the Pre-COP by Brazil, Italy and Japan with the support of India, and has so far been endorsed by around twenty countries. The initiative aims to quadruple the use of fuels defined as sustainable by 2035, compared to 2024 levels: biogas, biofuels, renewable and low-carbon hydrogen, e-fuels and e-methane.
The stated aim is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in sectors that are difficult to decarbonise, such as aviation, maritime transport, road transport and industry. The document, written in the same format as the negotiating texts, refers to the conclusions of COP28 in Dubai on the “transition from fossil fuels” and the G20 declaration in Rio de Janeiro in 2024, proposing a “technology-neutral” approach to accelerate the energy transition. Signatory governments commit to adopting ambitious national policies, harmonising carbon accounting systems and mobilising finance to reduce costs in emerging economies.
Some climate activism groups, such as CAN International, have criticised the initiative, describing it as a “dangerous distraction” from the real energy transition, and have refuted the idea that bioenergy can be a universal and meaningful “climate solution”, supporting only hydrogen from renewable sources and its derivatives, produced mainly using solar and wind energy and used close to the source of production.
They accuse this of being a greenwashing operation, carried out through the use of sustainability rhetoric to justify the continued use of fossil fuels. Increasing production on a large scale would in fact mean intensifying extractivism, especially in the Global South, with hydrogen infrastructure and biomass cultivation threatening natural ecosystems, human rights and socio-economic well-being.
The priority, comments CAN International, “should be the phasing out of all fossil fuels and the decarbonisation of energy and transport with renewable energies, as well as ensuring access to energy for everyone in the Global South”. This goal cannot be achieved by promoting expensive and risky technologies that place excessive pressure on the climate, communities and the environment, activists stress: dependence on these fuels risks undermining the transition away from fossil fuels and representing a dangerous distraction from a just transition. For this reason, the organisation has urged the Parties “not to sign the Belém 4X commitment on sustainable fuels”.
Article by Paolo Della Ventura, coordinator of the Climate and Advocacy section of Italian Climate Network.
Cover image: Rafa Neddermeyer/COP30 Brasil Amazônia/PR
